Key decisions for Strategy investors as MSCI review approaches on November 11
Published
By Qredo team

Key decisions for Strategy investors as MSCI review approaches on November 11

  • MSCI is set to reveal which companies will be impacted on November 11; Strategy's potential removal remains unverified.
  • Changes to the index will take effect following the market close on November 30.
  • On October 28, Strategy's shareholders approved amendments for daily dividends across four preferred stock series.

Investors in Strategy are facing a pivotal decision on November 11 regarding the company's presence in MSCI's global equity indexes. Any potential removals would take effect after the market closes on November 30.

On October 15, MSCI implemented new eligibility criteria. While Strategy's removal has not been confirmed, shareholders are concerned about how such exclusion could influence demand for their shares and future financing opportunities.

Additionally, on October 28, Strategy announced that its shareholders had approved changes allowing for daily dividends on four preferred stock series, based on preliminary voting results. Once the amended terms are filed and become effective, the new dividend schedule would begin on November 1 for STRC and January 1, 2027, for STRF, STRK, and STRD. This vote alters the preferred-dividend structure but does not resolve the MSCI index decision.

Understanding the new MSCI eligibility criteria

MSCI evaluates whether a company possesses substantial operating assets as the first step. Companies failing this initial assessment must then pass five financial-ratio tests, where ineligibility is triggered if four or more flags are raised.

Existing index constituents can only be removed if they fail the screen during both of their last two annual filing periods. MSCI may also factor in the most recent interim filing.

Previously, MSCI had identified Strategy, Metaplanet, and Upexi as potential candidates for exclusion under its criteria for non-operating companies, according to sources from TradingView.

Other companies, including Sharplink, Ton Strategy Company, Solana Company, and DeFi Development Corp., have also been placed on a watchlist for possible exclusion.

The implications of exclusion for Strategy

The possible exclusion could result in significant financial consequences for Bitcoin and companies like Strategy. A 2025 estimate from JPMorgan indicated that being excluded from MSCI indexes could lead to sales of Strategy shares totaling up to $2.8 billion, as reported by Bloomberg. These projections primarily involve investors selling off their Strategy shares. It's important to note that index exclusion would not necessitate Strategy to sell its Bitcoin holdings. Bloomberg also noted that potential selling could escalate to $8.8 billion in total if other index providers follow suit.

Membership in an index is crucial for generating demand for publicly traded stocks. Passive funds that mirror a benchmark index acquire shares of the companies included in that index and are required to divest from any companies removed from it. Consequently, exclusion would compel funds tracking the MSCI Global Investable Market Indexes to adjust their portfolios.

For a company like Strategy, index inclusion is vital as it ensures steady buying activity, including contributions through weekly 401(k) plans and mutual funds. Brian Dobson, managing director for disruptive technology research at Clear Street, emphasized this point to Bloomberg.

He noted that being removed from an index could create short-term selling pressure as investors who track that index liquidate their holdings.

The impact of exclusion is not confined to Strategy alone. Metaplanet, another Tokyo-based company, could also face similar repercussions.

Impacts on Bitcoin acquisition financing

Moreover, exclusion might have broader effects on the company's ability to secure capital.

Strategy usually raises funds for Bitcoin purchases through avenues such as common stock, preferred shares, and debt instruments. Its preferred securities include STRC and STRK.

According to a post by ZEROBASE on X, passive investing has become a pivotal factor in driving demand for Bitcoin treasury company shares. If MSCI's indexes exclude these Bitcoin treasury companies, it could have ripple effects on firms like Strategy.

Bloomberg reported that Strategy has already seen a decline in demand for some of its securities. The company faced a similar challenge last year when it was not included in the S&P 500 index.

Saylor initially propelled the company's growth by issuing common stock at prices exceeding the value of its cryptocurrency holdings. However, this premium diminished as concerns about dilution arose, leading to a shift towards preferred shares.

Demand for those preferred securities has also declined, as noted by Bloomberg.

Alexander Blume, CEO of Bitcoin-focused asset management firm Two Prime, indicated that it would become increasingly difficult for Strategy to sell equity and maintain its purchasing mechanism for more Bitcoin.

Blume remarked that digital asset treasury firms are often not perceived as legitimate businesses, which is why he was not surprised that some major index providers choose to avoid exposing their clients to such volatility.

Upcoming developments

The MSCI is anticipated to announce the companies impacted by its new classification rules on November 11, with implementation scheduled for November 30, 2026.

While Strategy's removal has not yet been verified, the financial consequences will depend on the final classifications and the responses of index-tracking investors.

Saylor has downplayed the potential implications of exclusion.

In an October interview with Bloomberg TV, he claimed that MSCI managed a